Pizza restaurants

Papa Johns Pizza

A 22-seat kitchen run by Eleni & Yassine, serving the dishes their grandmothers argued about on Tuesday nights in Kreuzberg.

14800 Yonge St, Aurora, ON L1G 1N3, Canada
3.4
145 notes from regulars
01 The story, in three paragraphs

Why everyone keeps coming back.

Nestled in the heart of Aurora, Ontario, Papa Johns Pizza at 14800 Yonge St offers a mouthwatering experience for pizza lovers craving authentic, flavorful slices crafted with care. This popular pizza restaurant is celebrated for its commitment to quality, serving up fresh, never-frozen dough that transforms classic pies into irresistible delights. Whether you’re a fan of a crispy New York Style Crust, oversized and foldable for the perfect bite, or the indulgent Epic Stuffed Crust filled with gooey cheese, Papa Johns guarantees a pizza experience that’s both satisfying and memorable.

The menu is a playground of bold tastes and comforting favorites. Imagine biting into a large Super Hawaiian pizza, generously topped with juicy pineapple and savory ham—just like Agnes Lai Leung (IG: aggie.food_life) experienced, who praised its perfect balance, flavorful toppings, and the delightful surprise of complimentary dipping sauces, especially the famous garlic sauce. For those who love a little extra zing, the oven-baked wings stand out—whether it’s the tender Unsauced Roasted Wings or the rich Garlic Parmesan Wings, each wing is a celebration of flavor. The variety of dipping sauces, from creamy Ranch to spicy Buffalo, lets every diner customize their meal to suit their cravings.

What truly elevates the experience at Papa Johns Aurora is not just the food, but the warm, attentive service behind it. Customers like Kim Mills rave about the personalized care from staff like Sinran who prepare half-and-half pizzas with customized toppings cooked to perfection. Professionalism and kindness shine through as noted by VAIBHAV GUJRAL, who applauded both the phenomenal BBQ-based thin crust pizza and the friendly team. Even when challenges arise—such as when Li A received an undercooked pizza—the management’s prompt and courteous response reassures guests that they are valued and their satisfaction is paramount.

The dining atmosphere, even when enjoyed as takeout, feels thoughtful and welcoming, with every order accompanied by extras like hot peppers and dipping sauces, adding little moments of joy. With prices that deliver great value—Houman Bagheri highlights a large veggie pizza packed with toppings and quality for around CA$15—Papa Johns Aurora emerges as a shining spot for casual, family-friendly dining or a hassle-free pizza night with friends.

In sum, Papa Johns Pizza in Aurora invites you to indulge in a perfect harmony of fresh ingredients, generous toppings, and savory sauces paired with genuine service. It’s a pizza destination where every bite is a testament to craftsmanship and care, promising an enjoyable and flavorful experience you’ll want to return to time and again.

03 Notes from regulars

145 notes — the real pulse of the room.

3.4
Based on 145 verified notes
5 76
4 13
3 5
2 11
1 49
All Garlic Knots Garlic Sauce Online Ordering Wings Toppings Dipping Sauce Pizza Quality Order Accuracy Wait Time Kind Staff
Agnes Lai Leung (IG: aggie.food_life).
2 month ago
First time had Papa John’s pizza. We ordered a large Super Hawaiian pizza. It’s so good and tasty that it’s not overly salty yet flavourful. They also weren’t stingy on the toppings. Yummy It’s a nice touch to include dipping sauce and a hot pepper with the pizza for free. For us first timers, it’s a surprise. I really love the garlic sauce!
Save Share
Kim Mills.
3 month ago
We had a different person make our pizza tonight her name was Sinran she did a fantastic pizza for us we always order a half an half worksless olives add pineapple the other half pepperoni only with pepperoni on top of the cheese and cook it well for us she knocked it out of the park ! Thanks again Sinran keep up the great job you do !
Save Share
VAIBHAV GUJRAL.
3 month ago
Me and my friend got a large thin crust pizza With chicken pineapple and onions with bbq as a base sauce. It was phenomenal. And the staff too is very professional and kind.
Save Share
Li A.
4 month ago
I ordered a pizza that wasn’t well done and ended up undercooked. The manager named Sunal handled the situation perfectly. He immediately exchanged it and made a fresh pizza for me. He was very nice, pleasant, and professional throughout the interaction, and made sure everything was taken care of. Excellent customer service and greatly appreciated.
Save Share
Houman Bagheri.
4 month ago
I tried Papa John’s Aurora tonight, and I am so happy that it has recently opened a new branch in Aurora. I had not tried other stores and it was my first time. I ordered a veggie pizza and it was worth it both quality wise and price wise. It was delicious and hot with four toppings and the price was around 15 for a large pizza. Hope they keep up with this quality food and service forever, and not for a short time. Good Luck
Save Share
Johnny Lai (LSFT).
5 month ago
Great Pizza and will definitely come back for more. Store is clean and bright!
Save Share
Jeremy Dang.
6 month ago
Ordered pizza, wings, and a sandwich. They were excellent and the special garlic sauce and pepper were nice additions.
Save Share
CJ Approved.
6 month ago
The folks at Papa John's here in Aurora are really nice. Enjoyed our short visit and the pizza is excellent.
Save Share
04 When to visit & how to find us

Hours & the door on Bergmannstraße.

Opening hours
Monday 10:00 AM - 02:00 AM
Tuesday (today) 10:00 AM - 02:00 AM
Wednesday 10:00 AM - 01:00 AM
Thursday 12:05 PM - 02:00 AM
Friday 10:00 AM - 03:00 AM
Saturday 10:00 AM - 03:00 AM
Sunday 10:00 AM - 11:55 PM
Finding the door

14800 Yonge St, Aurora, ON L1G 1N3, Canada

05 What makes this place friendly

The details you usually have to call and ask.

Service options
  • No-contact delivery
  • Delivery
  • Onsite services
  • Takeout
Popular for
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • No Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
  • Late-night food
  • Quick bite
Dining options
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • No Table service
Amenities
  • No Restroom
Atmosphere
  • Casual
Planning
  • No Accepts reservations
Payments
  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
Parking
  • Free parking lot
  • Free street parking
  • Parking
Saved this place? Add a note after your visit.

Notes from real diners are how the next person finds this table. 50–80 words is perfect.

Write my note